Top five players at your school, EVER

[Snake]

(Or any school)

Cut it anywhere you want it. College success, NFL success. Both.

Had a realization that Pitt has a sneaky good top five:

Dan Marino
Aaron Donald
Larry Fitzgerald
Darrelle Revis
Tony Dorsett

HM:

Mike Ditka
Curtis Martin
Mark May

[Cheb]

The top three for Michigan (at least for me) are easy; Tom Brady, Charles Woodson, and Desmond Howard. After that, it's a matter of taste and mood, and being the prison of the moment versus nostalgia.

[Zarni]

I’ve done Ohio State before, so I will do Akron

1. Jason Taylor
2. Victor Green
3. Dwight Smith
4. Charlie Frye
5. Domenik Hixon

[Snake]

I’ve done Ohio State before, so I will do Akron

1. Jason Taylor
2. Victor Green
3. Dwight Smith
4. Charlie Frye
5. Domenik Hixon

Mount Union?

[Zarni]

I’ve done Ohio State before, so I will do Akron

1. Jason Taylor
2. Victor Green
3. Dwight Smith
4. Charlie Frye
5. Domenik Hixon

Mount Union?

1. Zarni
2. Everyone else

[Phantom]

1J.J. McCarthy he was 27-1 as starter and way better than Ken Dorsey.
2.Jake Long
3. Desmond Howard
4 Charles Woodson
5. Tom Brady
6. Anthony Carter
7. Braylon EdwArds
8. Blake Corrum

[Phantom]

I’ve done Ohio State before, so I will do Akron

1. Jason Taylor
2. Victor Green
3. Dwight Smith
4. Charlie Frye
5. Domenik Hixon

What? Are you drunk?

[Zarni]

I’ve done Ohio State before, so I will do Akron

1. Jason Taylor
2. Victor Green
3. Dwight Smith
4. Charlie Frye
5. Domenik Hixon

What? Are you drunk?

Generally

[Bootz]

1. Jason Pierre Paul

The rest I can't put in any order so take your pick.

Marquez Valdez-Scantling
Andre Hall
Marlon Mack
Mike Jenkins
Kawika Mitchell

[Snake]

I remember the JPP pre-draft backflip video.

Legend.

[Kress]

Avoiding recency bias...

Brian Dawkins
Michael Dean Perry
Dwight Clark
Levon Kirkland
I dunno.... Fridge? Chester McGlockton? Terry Allen?

[CannonFire]

Don't really follow the football team much, but these 5 are the ones I remember off the top of my head. I can do much better with basketball.

Dan Orlavsky
Jordan Toddman
Donald Brown
Marcus Easley
Matt Peart

[BuccaNOLEer]

So many to choose from

Deion Sanders
Derrick Brooks
Fred Biletnikoff
Warrick Dunn
Walter Jones

[Navybuc]

Roger Staubach
David Robinson
Phil McConkey
Joe Bellino
Mike Wahle

[Obsolete]

Warren Sapp
Ray Lewis
Ed Reed
Sean Taylor
And a toss up between Andre Johnson and Michael Irvin.

[Buc2]

1. Jason Pierre Paul

The rest I can't put in any order so take your pick.

Marquez Valdez-Scantling
Andre Hall
Marlon Mack
Mike Jenkins
Kawika Mitchell

I can't argue with that. My list would have been similar. I might have put up George Selvie over Andre Hall. Still...solid list.

[Central_Buc]

Rudy Rudy: lol J/K

1. Joe Montana
2. Joe Theismann
3. Jerome Bettis
4. Tim Brown
5. Todd Lyght

[Phantom]

Not Jimmy Clausen??

He was great for shitty Notre Dame under terrible coach Charlie Weis

[MJW]

NFL Careers, then. Modern-ish.

Nebraska:
Will Shields
Kong Suh
Roger Craig
LVD
Neil Smith

Syracuse:
Jim Brown
Dwight Freeney
Marvin Harrison
Floyd Little
John Mackey

[Doctor]

Warren Sapp
Ed Reed
Ray Lewis
Jim Kelly
Michael Irvin

[__Chef__]

Warren Sapp
Ed Reed
Ray Lewis
Jim Kelly
Michael Irvin

Fight!

Warren Sapp
Ray Lewis
Ed Reed
Sean Taylor
And a toss up between Andre Johnson and Michael Irvin.

[Doctor]

I get grief for it but I'm not the biggest Sean Taylor fan. Physical specimen but sloppy player. Cut from the same cloth as guys like Lavar Arrington who would win fans over with the 1 out of 4 times abandoning his assignment worked to make a splash play while opponents thanked them for the other 3.

Had he not gotten the Tupac treatment he would've played long enough to have been exposed on and off the field. Especially as he grew more frustrated with a losing franchise.

Good player, but a lot closer to CB Aqib Talib than John Lynch, Earl Thomas, Kam Chancellor, Brian Dawkins, etc. Am I still lining him up need to Reed on my All Canes team, 100% I am. Just on a much smaller pedestal.

Also.... Booming a punter? In a pro bowl game?


Andre was a dawg. Can flip him and Irvin and I wouldn't argue.

[Obsolete]

I get grief for it but I'm not the biggest Sean Taylor fan. Physical specimen but sloppy player. Cut from the same cloth as guys like Lavar Arrington who would win fans over with the 1 out of 4 times abandoning his assignment worked to make a splash play while opponents thanked them for the other 3.

Had he not gotten the Tupac treatment he would've played long enough to have been exposed on and off the field. Especially as he grew more frustrated with a losing franchise.

Good player, but a lot closer to CB Aqib Talib than John Lynch, Earl Thomas, Kam Chancellor, Brian Dawkins, etc. Am I still lining him up need to Reed on my All Canes team, 100% I am. Just on a much smaller pedestal.

Also.... Booming a punter? In a pro bowl game?


Andre was a dawg. Can flip him and Irvin and I wouldn't argue.

I do agree that Jim Kelly should be on the list. He was a straight up machine for the Canes and was even one in the pro's...minus the superbowl lol.

[Doctor]

Minus 4 super bowls.

[Phantom]

Georgia boasts an exceptionally talented roster of players.

Champ Bailey
Matthew Stafford
Herschel Walker
David Pollack
Fran Tarkenton
Nick Chubb
Roquan Smith
Richard Seymour
Hines Ward
AJ Green
Terrell Davis
Garrison Hearst

[Snake]

Champ Bailey was a bad MF.

I forgot he was drafted by the Skins.

[Xandtar]

Hard to choose, so many, so many CB's I am passing on.

1. Joe Burrow
2. Justin Jefferson
3. Patrick Peterson
4. Y.A. Tittle
5. Odell Beckham Jr.

[Doctor]

Bailey for Porter may be the last legit 1 for 1 blockbuster ever.

[Phantom]

LSU undoubtedly has a plethora of talented receivers.

[Central_Buc]

NFL Careers, then. Modern-ish.

Nebraska:
Will Shields
Kong Suh
Roger Craig
LVD
Neil Smith

Syracuse:
Jim Brown
Dwight Freeney
Marvin Harrison
Floyd Little
John Mackey

For the Cuse would you consider McNabb top 10?

[Kona]

UCF for me

QB) Daunte Culpepper
QB) Blake Bortles
WR) Brandon Marshall
RB) Kevin Smith
QB) McKenzie Milton